Two different kinds of help
Premium tax credits reduce what you pay each month. Cost-sharing reductions reduce what you pay when you actually use care. They are separate programs with separate rules.
Why Silver plans behave differently
Cost-sharing reductions only attach to Silver plans. For a qualifying household, a Silver plan can end up with a lower deductible than a Gold plan while costing less per month. Comparing tiers on premium alone hides this.
How income is counted
The Marketplace uses your projected household income for the coverage year, not last year's tax return. Report changes during the year so your credit stays accurate and you avoid a reconciliation surprise at tax time.